
1.1 General issues with public address in large spaces
Ambient noise
Ambiant noise reduces intelligibility. For example, the loud noise produced by trains in railway stations could prevent
the listener from understanding a message properly. Also, the noise level can change drastically over time: in this
case, the public address system must adjust its diffusion level according to the noise level.
Intelligibility rule #2:
The public address sound system should emit at least 10dB above the ambient noise level.
Architectural constraints
Loudspeakers positionning is often restricted by architectural or practical constraints. Because loudspeakers are
not always welcome in places where aesthetics are important, they should be made discreet and as few as possible
should be used.
Speech intelligibility in large spaces
As seen above, speech intelligibility1depends on:
• Reverberation time. This is a caracteristic of the room acoustics and depends on the material of the wall and
the geometry of the room.
•Direct Sound
Reverberated Sound energy ratio. This depends on reverberation time, room volume2, loudspeaker to listener
distance, and loudspeaker directivity.
•Signal
Noise ratio. This depends on the ability of the sound system to emit enough energy to «cover the noise».
In large spaces, changing the reverberation time involves changing a significant portion of the wall material, and
most of the time, this is not possible.
Providing a strong signal to noise ratio is also important, but it is not enough to ensure intelligibility.
Therefore, in large and reverberant rooms, the most important parameter the public address must affect is the
Direct Sound
Reverberated Sound ratio. It is necessary to privilege the direct sound energy and avoid putting energy in the reverberated
part of sound. This can be achieved either by moving the loudspeaker close to the listener, or by using highly
directional loudspeakers.
In a large and highly reverberant room, it is necessary to privilege the direct sound energy for good
intelligibility results.
In large spaces, if the loudspeakers are to be placed close to the listeners, many loudspeakers are required. This
is not practical in such places because fixing loudspeakers can be difficult (very high ceiling, etc). Also, in many
cases, this will not give good intelligibility results because only the loudspeakers close to the listener contribute to
the direct sound, while all the loudspeakers contribute equally to the reverberated sound.
1Several indexes have been proposed to measure speech intelligibility. The most widely used of them is the Speech Transmission Index (STI).
Value 0 corresponds to extremely poor intelligibility, and value 1 corresponds to perfect intelligibility. It is generally considered that intelligibility is
correct above STI=0.55.
2Energy of the reverberated field is proportionnal to the ratio Reverberation time
Room volume .
6